Tom Hicks | November 11, 2026
Everybody’s an expert on Social Security. Especially the guy who hasn’t looked at his pay stub since 2019 but is absolutely certain the government stole all the money, the system is bankrupt, and he’ll never collect a dime.
Then there’s the fellow who thinks Social Security is some kind of government charity program for old people. Apparently, the 6.2% disappearing from his paycheck is just a voluntary contribution to Uncle Sam’s Christmas party.
Here’s the thing. If you’re working, you’re already paying into Social Security. If you’re retired, you may be depending on it. And if you’re somewhere in between, you might want to understand what the hell Washington is doing with a program that could eventually determine whether you retire comfortably or spend your golden years deciding which utility company gets paid this month.
Bernie Sanders wants to increase Social Security benefits by $200 a month. There’s also a proposal to change how the government calculates inflation for beneficiaries. And the program’s retirement trust fund is approaching a financial deadline Congress has known about for decades.
Naturally, Washington’s response has been to argue, posture, issue press releases, and occasionally discover that numbers exist.
Meanwhile, the rest of us are left wondering whether anybody in that building owns a goddamn calculator.
BERNIE WANTS ANOTHER $2,400. FINE. LET’S TALK.
Sanders wants to increase Social Security benefits by $200 a month. That’s $2,400 annually, separate from the regular cost-of-living adjustment.
For somebody collecting $1,500 a month, another $200 would make a difference. It might cover groceries, prescriptions, or enough of the rent to keep the landlord from developing another creative interpretation of the word affordable.
And before somebody starts screaming about Bernie giving away free money, remember that Social Security isn’t a birthday present from Uncle Sam. Workers contribute throughout their careers, employers contribute too, and benefits are calculated using covered earnings and eligibility rules. It’s social insurance rather than a personal savings account, so nobody is guaranteed to receive exactly what they paid in. But the idea that retirees are simply standing around with their hands out is bullshit.
Of course, increasing benefits costs money, and the program already faces a substantial financing gap. Promising everybody another $200 without explaining how to pay for it would be about as responsible as buying a Cadillac because your checking account still has eleven dollars in it.
Sanders proposes additional payroll taxes on higher earners to help finance expanded benefits.
Which brings us to something I’ve been itching to ask.
WHO THE HELL DECIDED RICH PEOPLE SHOULD STOP PAYING SOCIAL SECURITY TAXES PARTWAY THROUGH THE YEAR?
Let’s talk about the income cap, because this is where the math starts looking like somebody spilled bourbon on the spreadsheet.
In 2027, Social Security payroll taxes apply to the first $192,300 of covered earnings. Employees pay 6.2%, and employers contribute another 6.2%.
Consider two workers. One earns $60,000 annually and pays $3,720 in Social Security taxes. The other earns $600,000 in wages and pays $11,922.60.
The second worker pays more dollars, obviously. But as a percentage of total wages, the first worker pays 6.2%, while the second pays just under 2%.
And the Bastard has a question.
Why the hell should the percentage of your income going toward Social Security get smaller as your paycheck gets bigger?
Seriously. Somebody explain that without immediately reaching for a 40-page economic white paper and a glass of water.
There’s a historical explanation. Social Security was designed with a relationship between taxable earnings and the benefits people eventually receive. Earnings above the taxable maximum generally don’t increase retirement benefits, either.
Fine. That’s why the rule exists. It doesn’t automatically answer whether the rule still makes sense.
We don’t have to treat every decision Congress made decades ago as though Moses carried it down from Mount Sinai.
Sanders wants additional Social Security payroll taxes on earnings above $250,000. His approach leaves a gap between the regular taxable maximum and that higher threshold.
And frankly, I’d like to know why we’re keeping a gap at all.
If the program needs revenue, why shouldn’t all wages be part of the discussion? Why should somebody earning $60,000 pay the tax on every dollar while somebody earning $600,000 has a substantial portion of their wages exempted?
Removing the cap would raise another legitimate question: Should the benefits cap disappear too? If somebody pays Social Security taxes on a million-dollar salary, should retirement benefits be calculated on every dollar of those earnings? Or should higher earners contribute more without receiving proportionately larger benefits?
Those are real policy choices. They deserve real debate, including what removing the cap would raise and what additional obligations it might create.
But don’t tell me the current system is beyond questioning simply because it’s been around for decades.
We’ve also had congressional stupidity around for decades. Longevity isn’t proof of quality.

THE GOVERNMENT’S INFLATION CALCULATOR HAS A LITTLE PROBLEM
Every year, Social Security benefits receive a cost-of-living adjustment, or COLA, when the government’s inflation calculation calls for one. For 2027, that adjustment is 3.6%.
The government calculates it using the Consumer Price Index for Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers.
CPI-W.
Read that name again.
Urban wage earners and clerical workers.
And that’s the formula used to adjust benefits for retirees, disabled workers, and survivors.
Does anybody else see something worth questioning here?
A 35-year-old office worker and a 75-year-old retiree don’t necessarily spend their money the same way. One might be worrying about gasoline, commuting expenses, and childcare. The other might be trying to figure out how prescription prices increased again while the pills somehow got smaller.
There’s an alternative called CPI-E, the Consumer Price Index for the Elderly. It tracks spending patterns associated with households containing people age 62 and older, giving greater weight to expenses such as healthcare.
Historically, CPI-E has often shown higher inflation than CPI-W. Social Security’s actuaries have estimated that switching formulas could increase annual adjustments by an average of roughly 0.2 percentage points.
Two-tenths of one percent. Big damn deal, right?
Consider a hypothetical $2,000 monthly benefit increasing by 2.4% annually under one formula and 2.6% under another. After 20 years, the difference would be roughly $125 a month, or about $1,500 annually.
Suddenly, two-tenths of a percentage point doesn’t look so insignificant.
CPI-E isn’t perfect. It’s still experimental, its statistical sample is smaller, and it wouldn’t necessarily produce a higher adjustment every year. Those concerns deserve examination.
But I’d still like somebody in Washington to explain why we’re comfortable using an inflation measure that may not adequately reflect what beneficiaries actually spend.
Preferably somebody who has had to pay for a prescription recently.

SUBSCRIBE TO OFF SCRIPT
If you enjoy asking questions Washington would rather answer with a campaign slogan, subscribe to Off Script. We follow the numbers, challenge the assumptions, and occasionally point out when the emperor isn’t wearing any pants.
HERE COMES THE PART WASHINGTON KEEPS PUTTING OFF
According to Social Security’s 2026 trustees report, the retirement and survivor benefits trust fund is projected to exhaust its reserves in the fourth quarter of 2032.
That’s about six years away.
And no, Social Security doesn’t suddenly disappear when the reserves run out. Payroll taxes would continue coming in, and benefits would continue being paid. But continuing income would cover only about 78% of scheduled retirement and survivor benefits.
Without changes to the law, that’s roughly 78 cents available for every dollar in scheduled benefits.
The combined retirement and disability trust funds are projected to reach reserve depletion in 2034, with continuing income covering approximately 83% of scheduled benefits. The funds are legally separate, so combining them would require legislation.
Now here’s what bothers me.
Congress didn’t discover this problem last Thursday. The trustees have been warning about long-term financing problems for decades. Every year, another report arrives, the projections shift, and lawmakers act as though somebody just discovered a live alligator in the Capitol swimming pool.
Republicans accuse Democrats of wanting to raise taxes. Democrats accuse Republicans of wanting to cut benefits. Everybody promises to protect Social Security, usually while standing in front of a flag large enough to cover the national debt.
Meanwhile, the clock keeps ticking.
If you managed your household finances this way, the electric company would eventually turn off your lights. Congress gets to hold another hearing.
Know somebody who thinks Social Security is just an old-people issue? Send them this article. They might want to check their paycheck before arguing.
SO, DOES BERNIE HAVE THE ANSWER?
Maybe parts of it. But I’m not handing anybody a trophy just because they showed up with a proposal.
Sanders wants higher benefits and additional revenue from high earners. Republican Senator Bill Cassidy has challenged that approach and proposed a different financing strategy involving a separate investment fund.
Both approaches raise questions. Sanders needs to demonstrate how much revenue his proposal would generate, how much the expanded benefits would cost, and how far the changes would go toward closing the funding gap. Cassidy’s approach needs to explain its financing, investment assumptions, risks, and what happens if projected returns fall short.
I’m getting a little tired of politicians presenting their favorite economic assumptions as guaranteed outcomes.
And while we’re asking questions, why is every Social Security debate framed as a choice between raising taxes and cutting benefits? Is Congress incapable of examining the entire system and putting together a combination of changes?
Maybe the eventual answer involves additional revenue. Maybe it involves adjusting benefits for future higher-income retirees. Maybe it includes changes to retirement rules, although raising the retirement age would have very different consequences for somebody sitting behind a desk and somebody who’s spent 40 years pouring concrete.
A 67-year-old accountant and a 67-year-old roofer may both qualify for Social Security, but I’d wager their backs have very different opinions about working another three years.
Every proposal has trade-offs. The public deserves to understand them before Congress buries the details beneath another mountain of partisan horseshit.

IF YOU’RE 25, THIS IS YOUR DAMN BUSINESS
One of the biggest mistakes we make is treating Social Security like a conversation exclusively for people who remember when gasoline cost 35 cents a gallon.
If you’re 25, you’re paying into the system now, with decades of contributions ahead of you. If you’re 45, you’ve probably been contributing for more than 20 years and retirement is beginning to look less like an abstract concept. If you’re 75, the questions are immediate: Will benefits keep pace with expenses, and will Congress address the funding problem before it affects your checks?
Different ages. Same system. And all three generations deserve better than politicians treating Social Security like a campaign prop.
There’s something else younger people should understand. Social Security isn’t only retirement insurance. It also provides disability and survivor benefits to eligible workers and families. A young parent who becomes disabled or dies may leave a family depending on the program long before anyone reaches retirement age.
So the next time somebody tells you Social Security is just an issue for old people, ask whether they think disability and death politely wait until age 67.
They don’t.
THE OFF SCRIPT BOTTOM LINE
I want to know why Social Security payroll taxes stop at an income ceiling while the program faces a funding shortfall. I want to know whether CPI-E would do a better job protecting beneficiaries from inflation. And I want to see serious financial analysis of Sanders’ proposal, Cassidy’s alternative, and whatever else Congress manages to drag out of its collective backside.
Most of all, I want politicians to stop pretending that protecting Social Security means making another speech about protecting Social Security.
This is a program with real obligations, real revenue, and real people depending on it. The numbers don’t care which party controls Congress or who gets the best sound bite on television. They certainly don’t give a damn how many times somebody promises everything will be fine.
Washington has a math problem, and we’re all part of the equation.
Maybe it’s time the people doing the calculations remembered who has to live with the answer.
THE BULLSHIT DETECTOR 💩
Three claims. Three reality checks. Somebody open a window.
THE STINK SCALE
💩 A Little Whiff
💩💩 Something Smells
💩💩💩 Steaming Pile
💩💩💩💩 Full-Blown Bullshit
💩💩💩💩💩 Weapons-Grade Bullshit
1. TRUMP RENAMES JD VANCE “JUDAS DISLOYAL VANCE”
CLAIM: Donald Trump posted a Truth Social message attacking Vice President JD Vance and calling him “Judas Disloyal Vance.”
BULLSHIT: 💩💩💩💩 Full-Blown Bullshit
WHY: The supposed Truth Social post was fabricated. Fact-checkers found no matching statement on Trump’s account or in an archive of his posts.
Apparently, somebody decided the actual White House drama wasn’t sufficiently ridiculous and started writing additional episodes. Which is impressive, considering the competition.m Lead Stories fact-check
2. DAVE CHAPPELLE SNUBS A POLITICIAN ON SNL
CLAIM: Dave Chappelle deliberately refused to acknowledge James Talarico during the closing credits of Saturday Night Live.
BULLSHIT: 💩💩💩 Steaming Pile
WHY: Chappelle hugged Talarico during the closing credits. A misleading clip created the opposite impression.
That’s right. Somebody managed to turn a hug into a political insult.
At this rate, somebody will post a clip of a man walking toward his refrigerator and claim he abandoned his family because the video ends before he comes back with the milk. Lead Stories November 2026 fact checks
3. A FAKE FASHION SCANDAL IN BRITISH POLITICS
CLAIM: Images and video circulating online showed British politician Wes Streeting wearing a skirt and heels.
BULLSHIT: 💩💩💩💩 Full-Blown Bullshit
WHY: The outfit was digitally altered. Authentic photographs showed Streeting wearing a conventional suit.
Apparently, we’ve reached the point where somebody can change a politician’s wardrobe with software and invite the internet to have a meltdown about clothes the man wasn’t wearing.
There are actual government decisions worth arguing about. A computer-generated skirt probably shouldn’t make the emergency list. Lead Stories fact-check
ONE QUESTION
If you could change one thing about Social Security, where would you start? Would you eliminate the payroll-tax income cap, increase benefits, change the inflation formula, or tackle the funding shortfall another way?
And if you’re under 50, I’d particularly like to hear from you. This isn’t somebody else’s retirement we’re discussing. It’s yours, too.
MORE FROM TOM HICKS MEDIA
For something less likely to raise your blood pressure, Chart Collision explores the music that shaped generations. And if you’d rather yell at a football coach than a member of Congress, Panic Room Sports has plenty of opportunities for that.
Explore everything at Tom Hicks Media — The Complete Collection.
If you learned something here, pass it along. Somebody you know is probably convinced Social Security is going bankrupt next Thursday or that the government keeps everybody’s contributions in a giant shoebox.
And if you’d like more independent reporting with a healthy disrespect for political bullshit, subscribe to Off Script.
#SocialSecurity #Retirement #SocialSecurityReform #COLA #CPIE #BernieSanders #PersonalFinance #EconomicPolicy #OffScript #TomHicksMedia




I sure enjoyed the bump in take home pay in the last part of each year that my income exceeded the cap, but I never felt like it was fair to those that earned less. There's already an awful lot stuffed into most executive benefits packages. The government isn't obligated to sweeten those deals. There are several things about the cap I hadn't considered until reading this essay. When an employee hits the income cap and SS deductions stop for the remainder of the year, does the employer contribution also stop? If so, don't employers have a huge incentive to oppose raising or eliminating that cap? If Dems get a higher minimum wage, AND the SS income cap is gone, would the increased labor costs and the additional cash in consumers hands cause extraordinarily high inflation? When a self-employed person exceeds the income cap, do they avoid all SS taxes for income above the cap, or do they still pay what would otherwise be the employer's portion for income above the cap? I'm not expecting you to answer those questions, but I am curious enough to do a little digging on my own.
These are excellent questions, and frankly, they're exactly the kind of discussion I was hoping this article would start.
First, yes. When an employee reaches the Social Security earnings cap, BOTH the employee's 6.2% deduction and the employer's matching 6.2% contribution stop for the rest of that calendar year. Medicare taxes continue because they don't have the same earnings ceiling.
And you're right about the incentive. Eliminating the cap would increase an employer's cost of employing someone earning above today's ceiling. That deserves consideration, particularly for smaller businesses.
The inflation question is more complicated. Higher payroll costs could lead some employers to raise prices, restrain wages, reduce benefits, or change hiring plans. But whether that would produce significant inflation depends on how much costs actually rise, which businesses are affected, and how they respond. I wouldn't automatically assume a nationwide inflation surge.
There's also an important distinction between raising the minimum wage and eliminating the Social Security cap. The minimum wage primarily affects compensation at the lower end of the pay scale. Removing the cap directly changes Social Security taxes on wages above the ceiling. They could interact, but they don't affect every employer or worker in the same way.
As for self-employed people, they currently pay both halves of the Social Security tax themselves: 12.4% on covered net earnings up to the cap, subject to the usual tax rules. Once they reach the ceiling, the Social Security portion stops. Medicare taxes continue. If Congress eliminated the cap without changing those rates, self-employed people would face the full 12.4% Social Security tax on additional covered earnings. That's a substantial consideration.
And here's something else worth discussing: If we tax every dollar of wages, should we also count every dollar toward future Social Security benefits? Because those are two different policy decisions, and the answers significantly affect the program's finances.
I still question the fairness of a system where the percentage of wages subject to Social Security tax falls as earnings rise. But questioning the cap doesn't mean ignoring the consequences of changing it.
You raised legitimate economic concerns. That's precisely why I'd rather see Congress debate the actual numbers than spend another decade shouting slogans at each other.
Thanks for bringing some thoughtful questions to the table. I wish more of our elected representatives would do the same.