Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Morris "Moe" Koeneke's avatar

I sure enjoyed the bump in take home pay in the last part of each year that my income exceeded the cap, but I never felt like it was fair to those that earned less. There's already an awful lot stuffed into most executive benefits packages. The government isn't obligated to sweeten those deals. There are several things about the cap I hadn't considered until reading this essay. When an employee hits the income cap and SS deductions stop for the remainder of the year, does the employer contribution also stop? If so, don't employers have a huge incentive to oppose raising or eliminating that cap? If Dems get a higher minimum wage, AND the SS income cap is gone, would the increased labor costs and the additional cash in consumers hands cause extraordinarily high inflation? When a self-employed person exceeds the income cap, do they avoid all SS taxes for income above the cap, or do they still pay what would otherwise be the employer's portion for income above the cap? I'm not expecting you to answer those questions, but I am curious enough to do a little digging on my own.

THM's avatar

These are excellent questions, and frankly, they're exactly the kind of discussion I was hoping this article would start.

First, yes. When an employee reaches the Social Security earnings cap, BOTH the employee's 6.2% deduction and the employer's matching 6.2% contribution stop for the rest of that calendar year. Medicare taxes continue because they don't have the same earnings ceiling.

And you're right about the incentive. Eliminating the cap would increase an employer's cost of employing someone earning above today's ceiling. That deserves consideration, particularly for smaller businesses.

The inflation question is more complicated. Higher payroll costs could lead some employers to raise prices, restrain wages, reduce benefits, or change hiring plans. But whether that would produce significant inflation depends on how much costs actually rise, which businesses are affected, and how they respond. I wouldn't automatically assume a nationwide inflation surge.

There's also an important distinction between raising the minimum wage and eliminating the Social Security cap. The minimum wage primarily affects compensation at the lower end of the pay scale. Removing the cap directly changes Social Security taxes on wages above the ceiling. They could interact, but they don't affect every employer or worker in the same way.

As for self-employed people, they currently pay both halves of the Social Security tax themselves: 12.4% on covered net earnings up to the cap, subject to the usual tax rules. Once they reach the ceiling, the Social Security portion stops. Medicare taxes continue. If Congress eliminated the cap without changing those rates, self-employed people would face the full 12.4% Social Security tax on additional covered earnings. That's a substantial consideration.

And here's something else worth discussing: If we tax every dollar of wages, should we also count every dollar toward future Social Security benefits? Because those are two different policy decisions, and the answers significantly affect the program's finances.

I still question the fairness of a system where the percentage of wages subject to Social Security tax falls as earnings rise. But questioning the cap doesn't mean ignoring the consequences of changing it.

You raised legitimate economic concerns. That's precisely why I'd rather see Congress debate the actual numbers than spend another decade shouting slogans at each other.

Thanks for bringing some thoughtful questions to the table. I wish more of our elected representatives would do the same.

1 more comment...

Ready for more?